I just finished the first season of Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu. Truly amazing, thank you @lilkuya for bringing it up.
do you get the rakugo scenes? I dunno if it’s just me but I feel like the humor is getting lost in translation or something. those performance scenes never make me laugh. rest of the show fire tho. Watched like 4-5 ep last night. Prolly will finish the rest tonight
Watching dubbed anime reaction these past years have opened my eyes to some great dubbing. Steins Gate (better than the sub imo), Fate/Stay Night, UBW, Berserk, HxH, FMA and more. I used to cringe at dubbing but these comes off genuine.
All I want is an anime adaptation of Witch Hat Atelier by Ufotable, no other studio
do you get the rakugo scenes? I dunno if it’s just me but I feel like the humor is getting lost in translation or something. those performance scenes never make me laugh. rest of the show fire tho. Watched like 4-5 ep last night. Prolly will finish the rest tonight
Yeah I agree with you on that, I didn't get the humor but it is what it is. Although the stories didn't make me laugh, a certain story towards the end almost made me cry. I also really enjoyed the music.
All I want is an anime adaptation of Witch Hat Atelier by Ufotable, no other studio
The studio thats doing that Mushoku isekai right now would be a better fit stylistically. Ufotable is way too flashy
The studio thats doing that Mushoku isekai right now would be a better fit stylistically. Ufotable is way too flashy
That would be whitefox, and they lack the consistency to do the amazing art of the manga justice
That would be whitefox, and they lack the consistency to do the amazing art of the manga justice
No studio really would have the time and resources to do it justice besides Ghibli and KyoAni and they don't adapt works of that type. Same reason i don't want a Vagabond or Yotsuba anime
No studio really would have the time and resources to do it justice besides Ghibli and KyoAni and they don't adapt works of that type. Same reason i don't want a Vagabond or Yotsuba anime
"X manga is impossible to animate!" is a tired cliché.
Manga with unconventional art or way of storytelling like Punpun, Nejimaki Kagyu, BLAME! and Yotsuba I can understand.
But manga like Berserk, Vagabond and Witch Hat Atelier do not fall under this.
OPM is the best drawn manga from a technical standpoint I have read, and yet it got one of the best anime adaptations.
It took some of the most skilled and passionate animators but they made it work.
The openingsongs for the last Berserk adaptation looked great and it would have been amazing if the actual anime looked like that. And that manga is better drawn than vagabond, Inoues art degraded around the farm arc while Miura has always been improving his art, especially once he switched to digital (hot take I know).
The adaptation and improvement of technology in the industry itself is another reason why I don't believe in this.
So in short, couple this with their trackrecord and I am certain Ufotable would do it justice.
"X manga is impossible to animate!" is a tired cliché.
Manga with unconventional art or way of storytelling like Punpun, Nejimaki Kagyu, BLAME! and Yotsuba I can understand.
But manga like Berserk, Vagabond and Witch Hat Atelier do not fall under this.
OPM is the best drawn manga from a technical standpoint I have read, and yet it got one of the best anime adaptations.
It took some of the most skilled and passionate animators but they made it work.
The openingsongs for the last Berserk adaptation looked great and it would have been amazing if the actual anime looked like that. And that manga is better drawn than vagabond, Inoues art degraded around the farm arc while Miura has always been improving his art, especially once he switched to digital (hot take I know).
The adaptation and improvement of technology in the industry itself is another reason why I don't believe in this.
So in short, couple this with their trackrecord and I am certain Ufotable would do it justice.
I don’t agree at all that Berserks art got better but thats another topic.
Its not really that its impossible because Inoues art is too beautiful or anything. It just takes more effort for animators to make the characters stay on model when going with an art style like Vagabonds. They have to move realistically and stay on model at the same time which just takes a lot more effort compared to OPM. OPMs characters are more cartoony and its easy to do whatever you want to do with them. A Vagabond adaption will just be too time consuming for something that will probably not even sell that well.
I was not saying that Vagabond can’t be adapted, i just don’t see that the current state of the Anime industry can actually deliver on it.
I don’t agree at all that Berserks art got better but thats another topic.
Its not really that its impossible because Inoues art is too beautiful or anything. It just takes more effort for animators to make the characters stay on model when going with an art style like Vagabonds. They have to move realistically and stay on model at the same time which just takes a lot more effort compared to OPM. OPMs characters are more cartoony and its easy to do whatever you want to do with them. A Vagabond adaption will just be too time consuming for something that will probably not even sell that well.
I was not saying that Vagabond can’t be adapted, i just don’t see that the current state of the Anime industry can actually deliver on it.
An adaptation will never be 1:1 and already explained why Vagabond could be animated properly.
We'll just have to agree to disagree
I don’t agree at all that Berserks art got better but thats another topic.
Its not really that its impossible because Inoues art is too beautiful or anything. It just takes more effort for animators to make the characters stay on model when going with an art style like Vagabonds. They have to move realistically and stay on model at the same time which just takes a lot more effort compared to OPM. OPMs characters are more cartoony and its easy to do whatever you want to do with them. A Vagabond adaption will just be too time consuming for something that will probably not even sell that well.
I was not saying that Vagabond can’t be adapted, i just don’t see that the current state of the Anime industry can actually deliver on it.
Eh, don't think it selling well would be a concern, it's top 25 in manga sales, it's plenty of manga that have sold less and their anime never got cut for not selling or seemingly had issues selling
Watching dubbed anime reaction these past years have opened my eyes to some great dubbing. Steins Gate (better than the sub imo), Fate/Stay Night, UBW, Berserk, HxH, FMA and more. I used to cringe at dubbing but these comes off genuine.
Nearly every dub I’ve watched has been good tbh besides like Bleach.
Steins Gate in particular was great. I loved the voice actor for Mayuri she was so cute and Okabe was perfect as well
New Dr Stone was fire
They teaming up nigga
Watching dubbed anime reaction these past years have opened my eyes to some great dubbing. Steins Gate (better than the sub imo), Fate/Stay Night, UBW, Berserk, HxH, FMA and more. I used to cringe at dubbing but these comes off genuine.
HxH dub not good at all