given the current circumstances, would you say this album has aged well? i think this album marked a change in ye's attitude and is personally in my top 3 kanye albums

never listened to it

Ghost town is still amazing

why not

only Ghost Town

they’re both like 7s tbh at the highest

Yeah, and especially that Pizza Mike line.

Half of it did. The other half didn't necessarily age bad but it just didn't stand out enough to be deemed "essential" imho.

Ghost Town, Violent Crimes, ITAKY, and Wouldn't Leave are good/great songs with strong replay value.

But the rest? Meh.

KSG and Daytona outshined the album and aged better as whole projects.

That said, Ye's vulnerability and introspection on the album was very strong and honestly the best part of the album. It's too bad the music was more hit or miss than the emotion behind it.

It's funny you mentioned the album in lieu of Ye's recent antics cause it can honestly go both ways. Violent Crimes is still a classic song but Ye ended up being the very nigga he was dissing on the song lol.

if this is top 3 ye you are not a serious person

one of the worst albums of all time

was great when it dropped, is still great now

I like it. It came out a time when I was going through something mentally, and a few of the songs spoke to me a lot

i need you nailed to a cross with salt poured on your wounds for saying its top 3 ye

Bad album. Still bad.

I love it personally. I remember a girl I knew in high school was completely obsessed with it. The youth are all over it too.

Kanye fans always want to put his worst albums in their top 3 so they can act like he never fell off. No sane person thinks this is better than CD LR Grad or MBDTF.

At all lmao

Was always massively overhated and the absolute garbage he's been dropping since Donda just makes it sound more creative and inspired in comparison

Or yeezus or Pablo

Ghost Town & I Thought About Killing You are two all time ye songs for me

album does not rank anywhere near his top 3 let alone 5