no disagreements here

Forgot about rise of skywalker till i came in this thread now im mad and disappointed again

I have to try to actively avoid Star Wars now because of it, otherwise i get triggered to go on a tangent

Thank god The Clone Wars and The Mandalorian are good

The past 2 eps of Clone wars

real

aotc is goat lowkey

They need to fire whoever's decision it was to make the knights of ren random thugs instead of jedi students. Been waiting so long to see force users use other weapons besides lightsabers

phantom apprentice

One of the hardest lightsaber duels in SW

I would have even accepted film theory’s dumb f***ing video where they theorized The Rogue One Squadron were the knights of ren ( brainwashed troops that were frozen carbonated after their being captured from their mission )

It was really f***ing dumb but it would have been better then what we got

Imagine if we got something like this JJ why

Lol I still havent seen Rise either

Some of these lists make me want to gouge my eyes out.

The cap in this thread

For real lol. Don’t they explicitly say in TLJ that some of the Jedi pupils disappeared with Kylo when he burned down the temple? It was such an obvious (but still compelling) twist that they became the Knights of Ren, but JJ just decided to throw that plot point away and make them useless background characters this movie was so bad it’s ridiculous

They also just get obliterated in seconds lmao

Unpopular opinion but I really like the ST, TROS definitely had flaws with the way they brought Palp back but I'm not against the idea of doing it, plus it was cool seeing him again. It's the worst of the trilogy though, but it was a fun watch

TFA and TLJ top 5 though

I think TFA and Rogue One are both dope.

TLJ was ok, except for the whole Rose-Finn thing.

TROS was fun. I don't like how they did Ren's knights though. And Palp's fight could have been better.

Hoping to see Babu Frik again

Can’t believe Rian made a masterpiece and got spit on for it.

Rogue One and Solo were both really good imo, Rogue One more so.

Yep shame about the knights, sure they were only really inserted in the last movie but they could've gave them like one cool fight scene. I really liked the Palps fight actually, the whole ending sequence starting when Rey arrives at Exegol was fun, Ben Solo showing up, and hearing Anakin again made me so happy

When Palps showed his unlimited power and electrocuted the rebel fleet >>>>

i wonder how people would had felt if they just released the legends material trilogy on what happened after the ROTJ.

Cause while i feel the sequel trilogy feels empty, the legends story got quite stupid with the whole Palpatine thing but it had some interesting ideas

My episode ranking. I can take or leave solo and rogue one, I don’t really think of those as actual Star Wars movies even though I enjoyed them.

A New Hope
The Empire Strikes Back
Revenge of the Sith
The Last Jedi
Return of the Jedi
The Phantom Menace
The Force Awakens
The Rise of Skywalker
Attack of the Clones

Love them all tbh, episode 2 and 9 have some of the best moments in the saga but overall they’re so messy.

Aside from the top 3 this list could change tomorrow.

mine is with the two standalone movies

The Empire Strikes Back
Revenge of the sith
A New Hope
Rogue One
Return Of The Jedi
The Force Awakens
Solo
The Phantom menace
The Last Jedi
The Rise Of Skywalker
Attack of the clones

I did hear that in legends material there is a story about Palp coming back but I need to have a look at them, as I only know bits and pieces about post ROTJ from legends

Fair list tbh, respect it. Mine would be:

Empire Strikes Back
Revenge of the Sith
The Last Jedi
A New Hope
The Force Awakens
Return of the Jedi
The Rise of Skywalker
Phantom Menace
Attack of the Clones

someone throw the hands with JJ